Evaluation of Advanced Polymers for Additive Manufacturing

Abstract

The goal of this Manufacturing Demonstration Facility (MDF) technical collaboration project between Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL) and PPG Industries, Inc. (PPG) was to evaluate the feasibility of using conventional coatings chemistry and technology to build up material layer-by-layer. The PPG-ORNL study successfully demonstrated that polymeric coatings formulations may overcome many limitations of common thermoplastics used in additive manufacturing (AM), allow lightweight nozzle design for material deposition, and increase build rate. The materials effort focused on layer-by-layer deposition of coatings with each layer fusing together. The combination of materials and deposition results in an additively manufactured build that has sufficient mechanical properties to bear the load of additional layers, yet is capable of bonding across the z-layers to improve build direction strength. The formulation properties were tuned to enable a novel, high-throughput deposition method that is highly scalable, compatible with high loading of reinforcing fillers, and inherently low-cost. Additive manufacturing (AM) has the potential to offer many benefits over traditional manufacturing methods in the fabrication of complex parts with advantages such as low weight, complex geometry, and embedded functionality. In practice, today’s AM technologies are limited by their slow speed and highly directional properties. To address both issues, ORNL and PPG have developed a reactive mixture deposition approach that can enable 3D printing of polymer materials at over 100X the volumetric deposition rate, enabled by a greater than 10X reduction in print head mass compared to existing large-scale thermoplastic deposition methods, and with material chemistries that can be tuned for specific properties. Additionally, the reaction kinetics and transient rheological properties are specifically designed for the target deposition rates, enabling the synchronized development of increasing shear modulus and extensive cross linking across the printed layers. The ambient temperature cure eliminates the internal stresses and bulk distortions that typically hamper AM of large parts, and yields a printed part with inter-layer covalent bonds that significantly improve the strength of the part along the build direction. The fast cure kinetics combined with the fine-tuned viscoelastic properties of the mixture enable rapid vertical builds that are not possible using other approaches. Through rheological characterization of mixtures that were capable of printing in this process as well as materials that have sufficient structural integrity for layer-on-layer printing, a “printability” rheological phase diagram has been developed, and is presented here. Unlike existing additive manufacturing approaches which require larger and slower print systems and complex thermal management strategies as scale increases, liquid reactive polymers decouple performance and print speed from the scale of the part, enabling a new class of cost-effective, fuel-efficient additive manufacturing. · Multiple material formulations were developed and tested for printability · A small-scale benchtop reactive polymer extrusion system was developed and used to create small and medium scale test parts · A midscale reactive polymer extrusion system was integrated with ORNL’s blue gantry system and used to create small and medium scale (4 feet by 4 inches) test parts at high print rates (move speeds >3inches/sec) · Test bars were printed and shown to experience a cohesive failure as opposed to a delamination failure when tested in the z direction · An international patent was filed · Pilot scale production of reactive polymers was successfully demonstrated · Raster direction tests showed that a short, transverse raster results in stronger parts than a long, longitudinal raster · A small-scale active mixing system was successfully tested · A large-scale extruder (up to 500mL/min) was integrated with a medium scale gantry